
Bruins need Boychuk back/By S. Bradley
When he’s on the ice and healthy, Bruins defenseman Johnny Boychuk stands as an intimidating figure with his knack for bone-rattling open-ice checks.
But right now his presence might be inadvertently affecting the play of his teammates.
Judging by the performance of the Bruins’ healthy defenseman tonight in a 3-2 win at New York over the Rangers, it looks like everyone’s pressing to make sure they’re not the one jettisoned to the press box once head coach Claude Julien re-inserts Boychuk.
It seemed like every Bruins blueliner committed at least one gaffe, some which hurt the Bruins and some which they dodged like a turned over bullet. Were it not for Tim Thomas and his Superman-like ways – 34 saves, including 15 in the third period – the Rangers fans might’ve lost their voices from singing that “Goal” song.
Dennis Seidenberg and Mark Stuart redeemed themselves during the most critical stretch of one minute, 45 seconds of the game when the Bruins had to kill a 5-on-3 in the third period. Those two, who became a pretty regular pair at even strength tonight, were on the ice for almost that entire two-man advantage and used a couple shot blocks and some timely sticks in the passing lanes to make life a little easier for the rambunctious Thomas.
Of course, those two guys were on the ice because Andrew Ference failed to mind his stick and made contact with Sean Avery’s face behind the Boston net, and 15 seconds later, Zdeno Chara shot the puck out of the rink for a rare Bruins delay-of-the-game penalty. Chara got caught running around a few times over the course of the night, and Ference made a pass across the defensive zone earlier in the third period that Ryan Callahan nearly turned into a game-tying goal.
Seidenberg’s giveaway at the red line led to Marian Gaborik’s goal that cut Boston’s lead to 3-2. Matt Hunwick, shifted to the third pair with Adam McQuaid after the promotion of Stuart to Seidenberg’s side, made a handful of unforced giveaways, including one that led to two golden chances by Alexander Frolov and Gaborik just after the midpoint of the second period.
Stuart was sound but not great over the course of the evening. Maybe the only Bruins defenseman that didn’t stick out like a broken stick was McQuaid. But he only skated a shade more than 11 minutes over the course of the night.
So who comes out if Boychuk is ready to face Florida Thursday night? Obviously Chara and Seidenberg are givens based on their status as the Bruins’ best two blueliners. Ference has been strong most of the season, even with an increase in playing time in the absence of Boychuk. He can be a giveaway machine some nights and contributes little to the offense, but we know Julien likes Ference’s veteran savvy and leadership.
After struggling to start the season, Stuart finally seems to be hitting his stride and, more importantly, any puck-carrier within range. He has had a tough time getting out of his own end at times, but with third-pair minutes he should be able to play almost mistake-free hockey.
So that leaves Hunwick and McQuaid. Hunwick is Boston’s best skater on the back end, but he’s not exactly putting those wheels to use. He has only chipped in three points in 16 games so far, and you’re more likely to see him chasing after a loose puck he gave away than joining the offensive rush these days. A trip to the press box might totally shoot his confidence, but with McQuaid’s size, toughness and right-handed shot, the Bruins are definitely a better team. McQuaid is almost robotic in his ability to do what the coaches tell him and keep things so simple that you hardly ever notice him out there. That’s the sign of a solid stay-at-home third-pair D-man — you never even think about him.
The Bruins got enough great saves from Thomas and some timely offense to beat the Rangers despite the high-pressure New York forecheck exposing Boston’s Achilles heel on the back end. To make sure that heel is better protected once Boychuk returns, Hunwick has to sit until someone else proves to be the weakest link.









First of all, great line MCK… “McQuaid is better at defense than Hunwick is at offense (their respective strengths). Simple choice in my mind.” Simply put, just like McQuaid’s game.
PCL, I’m also in agreement with much of your assessment. Yes, our defensive game is great, but it’s on them to make sure the breakout begins smoothly. This is the NHL, not minor-peewee hockey. You can’t just throw the puck up the boards and blame the forward when it doesn’t get out of the zone. That’s bush-league stuff. NHL defensemen drool over those situations when they can pinch down and cause a disturbance. We’re making it easy on them. We do a good job of creating space by reversing the puck, but we need more clean, direct passes to the centre or a guy who has the confidence and patience to do more himself to create some space and allow the break-out to unfold. As long as we keep throwing blind passes up the boards, it’s going to look sloppy 9 times out of 10. When the wingers aren’t in position, you get what happened on Lucic’s goal last night. We aren’t making it THAT easy haha…
As for Chara. Are we angry cause he made one questionable pinch on the Dubinsky goal?? C’mon guys. You let Thomas off the hook for the softy. Well, Chara completes that pinch 95% of the time too. Kudos to King Henrik for a great pass. Maybe we should sign him to play D for us!
Hunwick is getting better with his chasing opponents from behind, because he was beat at the offensive blue line. He is also trying to be less of a passenger in the D zone. Sit Hunwick.
Wouldn’t mind seeing Kampfer up to get a look instead of Hunwick or McQuaid. Still need the skater/skill guy in the back even though Hunwicks struggled. Bartkowksi and Kampfer both outplayed Hunwick in camp, with Boychuk back in the line-up they deserve a taste at least.
In Hunwicks defense, he has been better than he was pre-season/1st 5 games or so. The D as a whole has looked sloppy (including Forward support) the last few games. Uncharacteristic, thankfully Timmy’s around to bail them out.
MCK, because he has better hands then Pallie, showed two years ago that he can play the position at this level and for the most part not be a liability.
I am pretty sure Chara is their best defenseman. One bad game won’t change that.
Why do some thing Hunwick is a better forward than any available forward?
PCL at the end of the day you and I are saying the same thing. What we would both like is a bit more talent on our blueline corps. I just happen to think that the defense corps is playing to the top of their abilities and doing a very good job. If you want Chiarelli to use some of the teams non core assets such as prospects and or draft picks to add another skilled D-man I’m OK with that.
You know, I kind of like Karl’s idea of moving Hunwick up front and using McQuaid more. I just don’t know who sits.
Good analysis of the D corp. Looks like Hunwick has to sit. I have one theory, that PC might leave Hunwick for show case purposes, and bench McQuaid until that trade happens. Whatever happens Hunwick is looking like his ceiling is reached. Time for him to go. Especially because we got a couple guys in Providence that do what he does, and its their turn to attempt the little guy d- man role.
Bench Hunstick. Or really any of them. Boychuk’s probably their best defenseman. It certainly isn’t Chara. Not after last night’s debacle.
I’m not debating the defensive play of the B’s blueliners, that is the strongest part of the team IMO. I see what you are saying about the forwards and agree with you to a certain extent, but I have noticed the forwards deeper in their own zone this year helping with the breakout/making themselves more available, which wasn’t there in the past. I’ve also noted passes to the forwards in some instances not being handled/received properly and they blow up off of their stick (Mr. Ryder I’m looking at you), but you have to admit that quite often the first pass just isn’t there. It’s too late, not fast enough and the forechecker either deflects it off of the d’s stick/ties him up along the baords or reads the pass and breaks it up inbetween the two players.
i’m a broken record, but i say keep mcquaid on the blue line and move hunwick up to wing. give the forwards some competition. guy who has the worst game gets a healthy scratch for the next.
PCL, your comments are way overstated. Before you look to fault the defense corp for the lack of clean breakouts ask are the forwards doing enough to make themselves available?
Look this isn’t the perfect set of defensemen, if they can improve the personnel then great, go for it. But the defensive corps currently on the Bruins is far from bad. In fact as a unit they are quite good!
I thought that the defense corps played an outstanding game last night. The first goal came on a shot from the outside to Thomas’ shot side. Thomas makes that save %95 of the time. The second goal came after the Rangers forward made a great play on Siedenberg and Stuart got caught trying to change. The other team makes good plays too.
I would prefer to see McQuaid than Hunwick in the line up, but that’s just me, the coaching staff might have better ideas.
Jim: “We tend to remember the mistakes and give aways coming from our defense corps, but don’t be too harsh in your criticisms. ”
People keep bringing it up, or “remember” them becuase for the past two years, at the very least, this has been a very large part of the reason why they have been ousted in the second round of the post-season. They get commit the turnovers, get pinned in their own zone and run ragged and then give up goals.
People may argue that they haven’t scored enough in those games to get the W, but I submit that without a clean breakout with crisp passes in stride to the forwards, it is nearly impossible to score or generate effective, consistant offensive pressure in todays NHL. One could say that right now and in years past, this is and has been the Bruins biggest problem in taking their play to the next level.
McQuaid should play. Hunwick doesn’t have it in my opinion. It would be nice to trade him.
McQuaid is better at defense than Hunwick is at offense (their respective strengths). Simple choice in my mind
I like McQuaid’s simple appraoch and straight forward game. Like you I would tend to play him ahead of Hunwick. Let’s see if Julien agrees.
We tend to remember the mistakes and give aways coming from our defense corps, but don’t be too harsh in your criticisms. The Bruins have the best goals against average in the league. Sure Thomas has been the greatest reason for this, but the Bruins team defense including the defense corps plays its part.
Nice win over the Rangers last night, hard fought and well earned.
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Matt Kalman, BostonSports93. BostonSports93 said: RT @TheBruinsBlog: New blog post Column: Boychuk-less Bruins D corps keeps showing its deficiencies http://t.co/8Zuncty [...]