Well, that will teach me to procrastinate before writing a column.
It was my intention today to write about how I am 100 percent sure Max Pacioretty did not embellish his injury after he was hit by Zdeno Chara March 8, but that the Montreal organization still had some explaining to do.
As any of us would do if injured, Pacioretty has put himself at the mercy of the medical staff. They told him he had a severe concussion and a fractured vertebrae, so that’s what he had. Everyone was praying and wishing him well, and breathing a sigh of relief he wasn’t in worse shape.
However, in the days after he suffered the injury, Pacioretty spoke on the phone to TSN’s Bob McKenzie and opened a Twitter account. Six days after the hit he was at a movie and the day after he saw “Hall Pass” and Tweeted his approval, he went to visit his teammates at the Bell Centre. Last week we found out he will start rehabilitating this weekend and could be cleared for contact as soon as three weeks from now.
Over that time, there have been whispers from people inside the Bruins’ organization and around hockey about how “severe” that severe concussion really was. You don’t have to a Bruin to know what Patrice Bergeron and Marc Savard have gone through, or to know how concussions have affected the likes of Eric Lindros, Keith Primeau and other players around the league. None of these concussed players were at the movies within a week. And rarely would doctors put such a specific timetable on a potential return from such an injury.
While no one would go on the record over the last couple weeks, I intended to bring up those issues on my own today. And then Mark Recchi dropped a verbal bomb on the Felger and Massarotti show on 98.5 The Sports Hub today. Felger asked Recchi about the Canadiens embellishing the severity of the concussion. The future Hall-of-Famer responded.
“Obviously yeah [they embellished it]. He does have obviously a fractured vertebrae. But the concussion was obviously really a non-factor. Maybe a day or two; maybe a day he felt it and then he was fine a couple days later. I believe, yeah, they were trying to get Zdeno suspended and they embellished it a little bit. I guess in terms of that side, I mean you have to look at it as they were trying to do anything they could to get him suspended. And I think the league sent a message that it was a hockey play and that’s the important thing that people have to understand.
While explaining that over his career he’s been checked into the stanchion maybe 40 times, Recchi added: “That was an interference play at best and the partition got in the way.”
Well now that someone of Recchi’s stature has thrown the dirty laundry on the floor, it’s up to the Canadiens organization — through their own public relations department or through the Montreal media — to explain this situation and keep it from smelling from here to eternity. Stories about “Miracle Max” in the papers and online just don’t cut it. If this was an embellishment of an injury report to smear a player’s name and get him suspended, it’s not just fraud, it’s also a major insult to Bergeron, Savard and every other player in every sport that has suffered and continues to suffer from a serious head injury. And if it wasn’t an exaggeration, the Canadiens should explain what it was.
Again, it’s nothing personal against Pacioretty, who’s living his life and taking his doctor’s advice. And maybe there’s a medical explanation for such a rapid recovery from such a severe injury. If the Habs want to stamp out any doubts surrounding the initial assessment of Pacioretty’s condition, they should respond to the questions and then we could all move on.










[...] that NHL veteran status. Later in the interview, Recchi would say that he had been checked into a stanchion 40 times in his [...]
[...] Mass. — After he accused the Montreal organization of embellishing forward Max Pacioretty’s injuries, Bruins forward Mark Recchi tried to defuse the situation [...]
btw, for all the genius bruins fans that are upset about Habs fans posting on this site, a little info:
This website is on the “Internet”. It’s not actually situated in Boston but everywhere in the magical interwebs that exist.
Second, habs fans outnumber bruins fans 10-1 at least. You guys have the patriots, redsox and celtics to compete with locally whereas the Canadiens are not only the biggest team in town but the most storied franchise in the history of hockey (ok you guys might not like that part).
We are insanely devoted to our team and we are everywhere.
Get used to it.
[...] it turns out, Recchi says his Wednesday accusatory comments about the Canadiens’ organization was all a ruse to distract from Zdeno Chara, who Quebec authorities are still reportedly [...]
If it’s ok to decide Chara deliberately tried to hurt MP by driving is head into the boards because of their past history, then I have every right to decide it’s strange that someone with Max’s injuries is able to resume playing professional hockey within 4-6 weeks after the injury occured. Everyone can make assumptions about what Chara was thinking without being an NHL player, but nobody can talk about MP’s injuries without being a doctor. I hope there is a great playoff style game tonight where nobody on either team gets injured, or does something stupid. Stop bringing up Savard or Bergeron, they both showed substantially more symptoms of a severe concussion than Max ever did.
Mark, your comments don’t make much sense. Why would Montreal embelish Pacioretty’s injury which resulted in him being out of hockey for a long time just to try and get Chara suspended. A suspension to Chara wouldn’t benefit Montreal where keeping Pacioretty out of the line-up hurts them. Duhhh…you’re a goofball especially since you’ve been in the league such a long time. Most veterens would simply take the high road on it. I guess you need the attention!
Sure seems like he went from deathbed to practice in a hurry if it was so serious.
Hiya, just want to say that a player speculating about a medical issue is pretty hilarious (I dont think Recchi finished High School, and while he might be smart, he’s not a doctor), and I don’t care what team you are on. Recchi said it, it was offside, but whatever. Consider the source (not an M.D), consider the intent (baited by sportsradio DJs, the Rush Limbaugh’s of leisure time) and voila. Instant tempest in a teapot.
What matters is the professional designations of the pros who made the call (Doctors do not trifle with political issues or blog hotspots); the need to communicate a very serious situation clearly and concisely (there is NO question Pacioretty has both a concussion and a broken vetebra); the subjective nature of concussions – just Google articles on brain injuries; the speed by which an individual heals. As a Habs fan I was simply glad to hear he’s recovering quickly.
Finally, just like Recchi doesn’t give a whit about whether anyone respects him anymore, Paciorietty likely doesn’t care whether Bruin fans are shocked he’s healing so quickly. That this “a whisper made a shout” in Bruins circles is odd, but understandable given how badly stricken both Bergeron and Savard were by their injuries. If the skate was on the other foot, you’d be wondering why Habs fans were condemning a quick healer, too.
Sean, unless there’s profanity, I have no problem with fans of any team weighing in. It’s your right to ignore them too.
MK
MattK. If this is supposed to be a Bruin blog and therefore an exhange of ideas (logical at that) why do you accept the posts of trolls who want to get into name calling? Thoughtful replies from fans other that Bruins fans should be posted and discussed logically by Bruins fans. Ernie’s and Laraque’s comments are not worthy of a response and do a serious discredit to normal Habs fans.
I think that the Bell Center (not Centre) will have to be considered the 21st century Lourdes and a center of pilgramage for all born again athletes. They could create a great montage of neck braces in the entry.
I can’t believe we have to deal with the Habs fans here again.
Savard is a oldie retired
Crosby played after that 1st hit from WAS?
Max is in better shape the nany bruins and had luck in is badluck injury…Haters he was at 1inch to get paraplegic and never play hockey again in his life!
Thanks Bernard. Thanks Burnsy. R.I.P
Nifty, that was Pat Burns leaving Lemieux unattented
Be careful Ernie with the name calling. Don’t want to block your comments.
MK
You and your Bruins Goons are absolute idiots.
Who the hell is Recchi for questionning the Montreal habs medical staff. Did Recchi finish his 3rd grade. This goes to prove that in Montreal we have a HOCKEY team…you have a goon team…see you in the series.
Wow. Drinking the Kool-Aid these Boston fans are. DDfour has it right. Recchi has worked for the Montreal organization and knows how great the medical staff is; second to none. He should know better than to get sucked int a question like that but it was ‘leading question’ that brought that kind of answer.
Listen, everybody in the hockey universe knew what wsa going to happen when Montreal was leading 4-1. We all knew it was going to get rough. So we knew it was going to happen, it happened, the ref said it happened by kicking Chara out ofthe game, and the NHL responds by saying, ‘It didn’t happen’. Really? So the NHL sent their best referees to the game as a mere coincidence?
Listen, Bruins are going nowhere. Any team that goons it up will be going nowhere. And you can sugarcoat it as you wish but just remember, having someone target any part of your body with the intent to injure is NOT an inherent risk of the game. Being hit by a puck on the face, getting a broken leg from a legal check, or tripping on yor own feet and smahing into the boards IS. But injuries caused by acts that warrant a penalty have to be eliminated from this game.
As an ex-hab Rex knows better than most what Montreal is about. Does anyone remember I think it was Mario Tremblay that wouldn’t let the trainer go on the ice to assist Claude Lemieux. Good times.
huray for mark finally someone other then don cherry has the balls to take on the bs from the montreal organisition man they get away with murder on and off the ice just watch the refs tonight i pity the bruins they won’t be allowed near a habs player this is so sick
Dragging Chara’s intent (or lack thereof) back into the discussion is irrelevant. That’s not what this article is about. He’s been more than gracious is dealing with all the garbage that has been thrown at him recently, give him credit. I’m very happy Max will be back, but Chara was never a murderous beast to begin with. MTL fans are perhaps the most passionate in the game, and I’ve daid before how much I love that city and its people, but that passion has maddened and blinded the entire fan base.
GET OVER IT PEOPLE…do you still cry about people that picked on you in high school?
Well, some of us dont seem so crazy now when we doubted the whole catastrophic nature of the injury….
Not surprised if true. This is how the Habs play on the ice so it comes as no shock that they take dives with off ice business as well
Yay, this old chestnut again!
Let it go and drop the friggin’ puck.
The hit was clean. Habs fans have seen that same play made their own players thousands of times with no complaint stop whining already. As for Recchi’s statements he is right and once again the Habs fans and media miss the point completely. Max was hurt. There is no doubt about it. Seeing him on the ice was sickening and there was concern for his life. Anyone saying he “flopped” or embellished it at that moment is just a moron. Recchi is not saying that at all and neither is Matt, great article by the way. What they are saying is that the Montreal organization embellished the situation. Name one other player who suffered a severe concussion and was able to do an interview the day after. This injury is probably the worst in sports and his speedy recovery is suspect. As a fan of the game I am happy to see he is well and ready to make a comeback, he is a very talented player, but the Montreal organization is making itself look bad here and they should explain themselves.
I think it is important to note that Recchi’s criticism isn’t directed at Pacioretty but at the Habs organization in how they reported the injury.
Personally I think he may be right that they over stated the extent of the injury in order to aggravate any suspension on Chara if the league opted for one.
He isn’t denying there is injury or accusing Pacioretty of faking injury. He is defending the hit though and the league’s decision that it was a clean hit with an unfortunate result.
Recchi future Hall of Famer??
Max not withstanding a severe concussion??
Max faked a ruptured vertebrae??
Zdeno did not go beyond what one abides to when playing the game of hockey?
Cmon you guys?
Stop fanning the fire about something that really happened. As for Max speedy recovery, well the information lies in the medecine books and it’s been well described by Ddufour and some other ones. Stop BSing please.
Don’t really care about any of this, but can’t stand this “had respect/lost respect” garbage. Kind of a pet peeve. First, a more apt term might be “admiration”. Respect for a fellow human should not come and go due to disagreement. I always cringe when I hear someone say “I really respect so-and-so” as if other lesser-people are not worthy of their respect. Second, how can one, single, disagreement make you change your mind so completely about a person that has built up good will and a solid reputation for years?
I’ve always had respect for Reechi over the years, regardless of what teams he has played for (including the Flyers). With his recent comments about Max, he has lost my respect as it is apparent he has become just another bonehead Bruin. The matter of fact is that Chara purposely drove Max’s head into the glass. An willful act that could of easily ended Max’s career or life. The fact that Max is supposedly progressing ahead of schedule should be cheered. The only thing being faked here is Chara still maintaining that he was fininshing a hockey play, eventhough the puck was 40 feet down ice. If Matt Cooke had performed the same “Hockey Play” we all know what he would of gotten for it.
I still don’t think Max faked or flopped. This is an issue with the Habs organization and they could easily answer these doubts we all have and shut us all up.
MK
Matt, I love the column and blog in general, but didn’t you just post a story days ago ripping people apart for questioning the severity of Paccioretty’s injuries?
The ringing people talk about is what you hear when you start to regain your facultys. The initial sound is not unlike the sound we use to hear in cartoons when someone gets hit with a hammer. It’s a reverberation that is hard to explain.
I wonder if the lapse in consciousness didn’t also have something to do with a broken neck, remember that the spinal cord is also encased in the same fluid as the brain, and is composed of the exact same kind of tissue (grey neurons and the cells that protect them). The brain stem and spinal cord take care of many of your unconscious functions (i.e. heart beating, release of stomach acid etc.) which means that if it were to be disrupted we may also see loss of consciousness resulting in what looks like a severe concussion as the dictionary definition would prescribe, but with less severe symptoms due to lack of damage to the brain itself.
That’s the best guess I can take at why his concussion may have seemed severe and actually have been less onerous than Krejci’s.
If you have kids you worry about their health especially if they play contact sports. Yet as a society and in good conscience we sanction events where the sole objective is to render your opponent unconscience. Which according to medical journals is a severe concussion.
DDFour- I have been the recipient of a “severe” concussion, and believe me, you don’t go to the movies and hang out at the rink, twitter, etc. You can barely get out of bed for the first couple days, and then you have to worry about dizziness, nausea, balance problems, light sensitivity, and the list goes on.
If you go by the length of time someone is unconscious, then he doesn’t even fall under a moderate label, as he was only out, or had his eyes closed for about 30 seconds. I’m glad he’s ok, but I do think the Montreal folks embellished it, just like they do everything else.
DDfour, good enough explanation for me. But his recovery time to me as someone not in medicine is pretty extraordinary only based on the injuries Bruins fans have seen the past few years. Perhaps the mistake is made comparing one concussion to another when even a doctor says they shouldn’t be compared to each other.
“A severe concussion may involve prolonged loss of consciousness with a delayed return to normal”.
From: emedicinehealth.com
The criteria that merits a ‘severe concussion’ prognosis is usually based on the amount of time someone losses consciousness, and not the symptoms that may follow one. A mild or light concussion may have a longer recovery than one that is immediately classified severe.
The immediate prognosis was spot on (look it up).
If Recchi is willing to go on record about this, then I can’t imagine there is no truth to at least some of it. It seems like someone may have embellished the injury not thinking that anyone would pay attention to his recovery time, a sort of descision that is made quickly to help the Canadiens cause with no time to think about future ramifications. Hopefully the Habs can answer some of these questions and if they can then so be it.
Recchi should be smarter than this. Even if the habs embellished, relief that the guy is recovering far outweighs distaste for how that snivelly franchise conducts itself. B’s sound like they’re disappointed he wasn’t more badly hurt. That’s just not right.
Maybe the Montreal PD city attorney should open up a medical fraud investigation…
Preach on, Brother Kalman!
Maybe the Bruins should send Savard to Montreal for rehab. That way we can have him available for Round 1 in 3 weeks.
Great post Matt.