Worst case scenario has come to pass for Bruins’ back end
BOSTON – General manager Peter Chiarelli and the Bruins cannot say they weren’t warned.
Fans can’t claim they had no idea this would happen.
Every year teams struggle to keep their defensemen healthy toward the end of the season and into the playoffs. The ones that have the weapons on hand to fill in the gaps are the ones that march on.
Philadelphia’s surviving without Chris Pronger because they have Nick Boynton to supplement a strong five-man corps. Buffalo has plugged in confident rookie Marc-Andre Gragnani where needed.
The Bruins? They’re Plan B when Zdeno Chara had to leave the lineup was Shane Hnidy, an affable chap with plenty of NHL experience, but with wheels that’ve grinded to a crawl and only three games of action under his belt this season after major shoulder surgery last fall.
Yes, spending to the salary cap just doesn’t buy you what it used to now, does it? To be fair, the Bruins have invested a ton in their goaltenders and their scorers and their pluggers and that’s gone so well … well, you get the point.
The Bruins found out two years ago that they needed more in reserve once Andrew Ference and Matt Hunwick went down. They went into last year’s playoffs with not enough to make up for the absences of Dennis Seidenberg and Mark Stuart. So this year they rolled the dice with Hnidy and rookie Steven Kampfer as their emergency defenseman. Fool them once, OK. Fool them, twice. So ahead, fool them again.
Well Kampfer became a lineup casualty himself by suffering a knee injury during an AHL conditioning stint last week. Nonetheless, he had played his way out of the lineup by making the type of decisions with the puck you expect out of a first-year pro defenseman. And his defensive game is not ready for the NHL playoffs.
You can argue that the Bruins, after the trade of Stuart left them a little thin on defense, lacked the competition within the team that has helped them succeed in the past. That could’ve contributed to the drop-off in play of Adam McQuaid and Johnny Boychuk. Even if one of them was really struggling, odds are he wasn’t coming out of the lineup.
That doesn’t matter now. What matters now is that even if Zdeno Chara comes back from his recent bout with an illness and helps the Bruins push their playoff run longer than a couple games, someone else is bound to go down. And it’ll be up to Hnidy to save them again. Heaven forbid the Bruins lose two guys at once, Don Sweeney might have to suit up.
This blog advocated bolstering the back end time and again all season. Often the stories were repudiated by talk of how great everyone was playing and how none of the defensemen could conceivably come out of the lineup if additions were made.
Well, the chickens have come home to roost folks. And by chickens I mean the type that have their heads cut off and run around in their own zone and make passes on the breakout without looking so that they become giveaways and goals against.
The warning signs were posted and the Bruins ignored them. Now they’re on the verge of a crash.

thanks for giving Wides his due
Matt you are right. transition game and hot potato. I like Boychuk but he buckled when you needed him to get the job done.
Speed and skill? Well, I think speed is a huge problem for boston. Look at Montreal’s no-namers. Pyatt, Eller…who are these guys? Why are they such good forecheckers? Blinding speed. The deep forward rarely has time to do a nice skill play. He just needs to rush the D (cough Kaberle) and make him screw up. During the regular season, these guys can look useless when Campbell and Lucic are pounding mud holes in them but in the playoffs, their speed has help a lot.
You know, back in 2003, Ryder used to skate pretty fast back in 2005…
Also, if you dig in, you’ll read that I liked the Kelly deal. I like him as a C between Wheeler and Ryder to see if it could get them going. And they blew that up 2 days later.
MK
Rob-
That’s fair.
But just to make my point,I wanted them to spend their money on D or keep Stuart long before that and instead they went for Peverley and Kelly in addition to Kaberle. Once they were in their cap situation they were in, Hnidy was the best they could do. And I think that was my main point. If that didn’t come through in the story, I’ll do better with that down the road.
Thanks, MK
Yet you seemed so confident when you wrote this…
http://www.thebruinsblog.net/2011/02/23/sheriff-shane-could-solidify-bruins-back-end-for-stretch-run/
Waffler.
[...] The Bruins were playing with fire when it came to defensive depth, and it burned them in Game 2. [...]
Wideman’s lateral movement and his ability to spin of a checker and make a nice pass didn’t fly in this town. People only noticed him getting knocked off the puck because his balance isn’t great. You can still be a good skater and not have the best balance. Yeah Dave I’m with you. Montreal is making our D make skilled plays and guess what. This town wants the McQuaids and the Seidenbergs not a guy that actually generated offence. Sure Wides had his moments but other teams want him. I wonder why?
Hate to say it, but they could use Wideman skating the puck up ice instead of guys trying to force 80 foot passes.
Actually I think we don’t have enough players with both skill and skating. It is almost like we do a fine job of obtaining guys who have one or the other but rarely both.
I do think Seguin has skill and skating, but he needs to develop more.
Ference was pretty good this season, but he was atrocious last night. Not Boychuk atrocious, but pretty damn bad. Not that anyone looked good. Sidenberg, McQuaid, Kaberle. The defense has been a real stinker.
You can grind out wins in the regular season when teams can’t be bothered to pay the price especially the second night of a back to back. The ability to ramp up our play is limited because of the skill to skating ratio. We don’t have enough skill or skating.
i really don’t think Chara is going to make much of a difference this team is not built right for todays game i think we need to start over first on the list a new young coach who is in touch with the todays game is played
Yeah I think Ference has looked good this year, but I also think he and McQuaid are best as third pair D-men. They both seem to fall off a bit when moved to the top line (although Ference played pretty well with Chara during Boychuk’s absence).
While I still don’t mind the Wheeler trade for Peverly (I think Peverly is an upgrade) I think Stuart probably wasn’t worth it.
Still luke warm on Kaberle. I am just not sure he is the right guy, and I kind of wonder if we wouldn’t do better to eat the bad end of that trade and look for somebody else this summer.
Either way my biggest concern was that we would have to go the pressbox for a defenceman and it came true-although I never would have dreamed the guy down would be Chara.
no big surprise here.thomas has made this team of average players look like contenders.Sit seguin play pallie and ryder because they give us the best chance not too loose.I beleive if they made better trades and played seguin from the start we might of had a chance.ryder,pallie,campbell,thortnon,kelly.thats almost your entire forward team impressive…..huh
Ference has looked pretty good.
Don Sweeny ? He had a job for one reason he played next to Bourque who make Hnidy look good. But there lies the Boston mentality. Orr. Bourque, and Charra. No depth sfter that at all. I think Kaberle can be a great assesit when he times things better with the forwards. But Seidenberg, Ferrence, Boychuck, Mcquaid aka Bruce Shoebottom are mid level talent. Look at the way a Ducan kieth or it kills me but he’s good Suban can rush a puck it’s pretty awsome that these guys can skate through the other nine guys on th ice like they are a ghost. Ah but I forgot on this rant we build our team from the goal out which has been highly effective for the last 39 years way to go.
Chara had better not be too sick to play in the next game.
also, I hereby invite y’all to mount your own comeback with the game I just made by clicking on my name.
My biggest fear was that a strong forecheck was going to shut down the D. I haven’t seen that strong of a forecheck. What I’ve seen is just really poor play, from bad passes to missed assignments. This team looks like the pressure got to them before the playoffs even began.
“….[Go] ahead, fool them….”