There are a lot of different ways Bruins head coach Claude Julien and his staff can go about limiting the negative of impact of having to play without Patrice Bergeron, if the veteran center has to miss any games with his mild concussion.
Replacing Bergeron with any current personnel is impossible. At 25, Bergeron has become an outstanding combination of a shutdown center and a point-producer. The last several weeks, he’s also shown off a higher gear than he’d every displayed for the Bruins during the team’s playoff run.
The Bruins’ lines have performed with such great chemistry through the last nine postseason games — seven wins — undoubtedly Julien will want to limit the changes he makes. But just plugging Chris Kelly into Bergeron’s spot and putting rookie Tyler Seguin on right or left wing with Michael Ryder and Rich Peverley in Kelly’s spot might not get the job done in the upcoming Eastern Conference finals series against Tampa Bay.
Kelly, who along with Gregory Campbell shared Bergeron’s center shifts in Friday’s Game 4 against Philadelphia, is certainly skilled and responsible enough to fill Bergeron’s skates. Such a maneuver might be the simplest way to fill out the lineup, but might also leave the Bruins’ third line deficient defensively.
Peverley has speed and is an excellent faceoff man. His defensive instincts and physicalilty, however, are only average. On any given night, you still can’t be sure what you’re going to get from Ryder in the defensive zone. And we know where Seguin is lacking in terms of his responsibility and willingness to get dirty along the boards and in the corners.
That’s where Campbell comes in. While he’s been cast as a fourth-line energy center most of the season, he has also shown a little more offensive bent than any Boston fourth-line center in recent years. If Julien wants to make sure he has three lines with enough defensive ability to be on the ice even against a difficult match-up from Tampa Bay, he could move Campbell between Peverley and Ryder, and stick Seguin between Daniel Paille and Shawn Thornton.
Except the games that have been one-sided on the scoreboard, that fourth line has barely received a handful of shifts anyway. That would allow Seguin to get his feet wet in his first foray into the Stanley Cup playoffs and limit the chances of him making a costly mistake.
Of course, breaking up Paille, Campbell and Thornton is risky because those three have played so well as an energy trio. And splitting Kelly, Peverley and Ryder could cost the Bruins as well. Should Seguin make a meteoric improvement in the playoffs from his performances at the end of the regular season, maybe he gets a few shifts between Marchand and Recchi in an effort to get that offensive boost general manager Peter Chiarelli said the rookie could provide.
In the interest of not shaking things up too much, I would expect Julien to start a Bergeron-less game against the Lightning with these lines:
Lucic-Krejci-Horton
Marchand-Kelly-Recchi
Seguin-Peverley-Ryder
Paille-Campbell-Thornton
But once it comes down to crunch time — the third period — I would expect to see something more like this:
Lucic-Krejci-Horton
Marchand-Kelly-Recchi
Peverley-Campbell-Ryder
Paille-Seguin-Thornton
David Krejci, during games at home with the last change, will definitely get the prime defensive assignment against whichever Tampa Bay line the Bruins consider the one they have to shut down. On the power play, they could plug Seguin into Bergeron’s spot up front in order to get him more involved or opt for the experience of Peverley with Recchi and Marchand on the man-advantage.
The Bruins might be able to win a game or two without Bergeron. It’s unlikely they’d be able to win a series. But you can’t put anything past this surprising group of Bruins who seemingly believe they’re capable of anything.
Making up for Bergeron’s absence, however, is going to be a complicated task that’ll require many players stepping up their game even more, and Julien and his staff getting creative with their in-game changes and adjustments.










[...] Boston Bruins: Tyler Seguin will be in the lineup for Game 1 of the Eastern Conference Finals, playing for Patrice Bergeron(notes). But there is no way in hell they let him play center. [...]
[...] Boston Bruins: Tyler Seguin will be in the lineup for Game 1 of the Eastern Conference Finals, playing for Patrice Bergeron. But there is no way in hell they let him play center. [...]
[...] that said, something of a narrative has come forth from theArticle source: [...]
[...] that said, something of a narrative has come forth from the Bruin blogosphere in the last couple days that the loss of Patrice Bergeron [...]
Every winger is going to have his moments along the wall. You can’t clear it 100% of the time or no one would score. I agree with Derek. I’ve seen him look like Datsyuk where he not only stole the puck but he turned it up ice and created a chance. He has led the charge when it comes to playing a complete game and he may have given up a goal or two to be back in a good spot defensively. He has been a huge factor in his lines success. Every line gets hemmed in at some point. That’s the beauty of hockey.
For the first 2 periods and if behind in 3rd, It will be:
Lucic-Krejci-Horton
Marchand-Peverley-Recchi
Seguin-Kelly-Ryder
Paille-Campbell-Thornton
I would need to vehemently disagree with assessment of Ryder – “you still can’t be sure what you’re going to get from Ryder in the defensive zone” – maybe in regular season, but in the postseason, he has been beast on the back check and good on the boards getting the puck out. If Seguin is going to play any meaningful minutes, it will be with Kelly.
Cheers.
My first post was to put Kelly in Bergy’s spot. He is more suited to play with those guys over Campbell. A third line center playing up one spot isn’t too big a jump. I’m not sure Gregory could finish or create as well as Chris. But like Bo said that does mess up two lines as opposed to just moving Campbell. I’m sure there will be some tinkering and the coaches will adjust. My first thought was to promote Kelly and Paille up one line. Paille has earned the right to at least be given the chance. Danny wasn’t drafted as a fourth liner.
Kelly is just the most comparable to Bergy I think. Seems to be the most logical fit.
Kelly is someone I hadn’t thought of between Marchand and Recchi it could work. Campbell is interesting as well as he is such a hard worker and has been playing well but I’m sticking with Peverley as Julien’s choice to move up.
Crosby skated away from his first concussion and continued to play in the game. I am not sure skating away without being out of it is necessarily promising.
I would absolutely love for Bergeron to come back for the play offs, but I am just not convinced he is going to recover like that and not sure it is worth the risk to him to push him back too soon.
I kind of like the idea of double shifting Campbell a little bit and keeping the first and 3rd lines mostly intact and using Seguin minimally.
I don’t think you can put him with Thornton and Paille and expect him to perform.
Honestly I think putting him between Peverly and Ryder might get the most bang for the buck with Seguin-Peverly has good hands and good eyes and Ryder and Seguin have shown that they have pretty good chemistry.
I know Julien generally likes to roll 4 complete lines but for the Tampa series line tweaking may be the best option to cover for Bergeron.
I also think Kelly may have the better defensive instincts when it comes to shutting down Stamkos and St. Louis. I just see Peverly or Campbell fitting better between Marchand and Recchi.
Dan
I am pretty sure he is out for a week minimum by league rules. Also, DK missed 6 games. That is like 2 weeks. Tough call right now, but if I were betting, I would bet Begeron is done for the year
@Karl really? Its waaaaay too early to determine seguin a bust. Why? Because he’s playing on a team with so much depth that he couldn’t crack the top 6? Doesn’t make him a bust. If Boston got Hall instead of Seguin it would be the same situation. Only reason Hall had a good season is because Edmonton’s roster is so shallow that they needed Hall to play top line and top minutes.
I still think they should move Kelly to 2nd line, paille to wing on the 3rd and Seguin 4th line.
I don’t see Bergeron’s concussion being a big concern because Bergeron got right up nd skated off without any problems. He didn’t show any signs of being in trouble when it happened. Even when Krejci got concussed earlier this season he wasn’t able to get up let alone shake it off and skate right off and he only sat out a few games. If Bergeron misses a game or 2 max, it would still be more precaution than anything else.
You’re totally right nifty. Anyway, Seguin won’t have any chance to prove anything with the 3 or 4 minutes of ice time he’ll get. Julien will change his lines non-stop during those games by playing mostly 3 lines like Tampa does with little switches here & there. No doubt Campbell will be the top beneficiary of those moves with his ice time skyrocket to close to 20 minutes/game. As long as TT keeps on playing this, that Bergy-less lineup can easily beat Tampa. Let’s just hope he’ll be back for the Finals.
MCK,
You left out the best example. Joe Thornton only had 3-4-7 in 55 games during his rookie year. Hopefully, Seguin will have a career like Big Joe’s.
It’s become trendy to dog on Seguin. I’m pretty sure Karl was a segzy supporter at one time.
I think if Bergy doesn’t come back they don’t win the title. They may get by TB, but that is much closer now
Putting Seguin with Paille and Thornton is useless. They don’t play his game. He either plays with people with real offensive talent or they put someone else in there with Paille and Thornton.
One option is to not really have a 4th line. You can keep the top line together, move keep Kelly and Peverly and Ryder together and rotate Paille and Campbell up to the Bergeron line, occasionally tossing out a line with Thornton or Seguin on it. Like I said though, Seguin looked his worst with Paille and Thornton as his linemates. I would rather have Caron called up, move Soup up a line or two (Bergeron’s spot?) and put Paille in the middle of Thorny and Caron. I think ultimately we will see a bunch of guys rotating up and some double shifting out of Kelley and Peverly.
Karl, if Seguin doesn’t light it up, do you seriously think he is a bust? cmon man. Did you think Bobby Ryan was a bust after his first season 5/5/10 in 23 games? What about Couture (5/4/9 in 25 games)? Kessel was only 11/18/29 in 70 games in year 1 and 19/18/37 in 82 games in year 2. He is a one way player, true, but now he is a 30 goal scorer. Cut Seguin some slack
just go with 3 centers (krejci, kelly, soup) and let them take turns running bergy’s line based on the situation. minimal impact here and claude did it during game 4.
hope rex has enough in the tank to play the pk.
segzy now has a chance to prove he wasn’t a top pick bust.
I have to agree that Tampa has a real edge now. Seguin’s speed will help but Bergeron has evolved into one of the best in the NHL. He can’t be replaced at this point. Maybe Seguin can get some good experience out of a bad situation.
If Seguin was scratched for the first two series, then I would think Claude is going to avoid using him even when he’s not scratched. I think Kelly gets moved up to the 2nd line and Paille gets the call up to 3rd to fill the Kelly spot. If anyone looks tired then Campbell can fill in pretty much anywhere.
Seguin is a defensive liability and terrible on face-offs so I. Interested to see where he gets used.
If I was Coach Julien I would be looking to Greg Campbell to pick up as many Bergeron minutes as possible. The problem is that Seguin doesn’t really fit the fourth line roll. So Julien will have to spot Seguin between Marchand and Recchi so as to give Campbell a “blow” from time to time. Greg Campbell is the key, he is a very solid, versatile player I suspect Julien is going to lean on.
Campbell is a competitor- I bet he would relish the chance to double shift with the Rex/Marchy line and the 4th line. Or, you could have Campbell on the 2nd line and juggle the 4th line center position between him, Kelly and Peverley. Campbell is like a Bergeron ultralite, but he could still win come battles and create some chances. I pray we see him on that line; breaking up that third line is not something I want to see. A couple of things to note:
-So far in the playoffs, Tampa has dressed 7 defensemen and 11 forwards. So if the B’s were to use Seguin as a sort of “option” player, the rest of the team wouldnt necessarily be gassed.
-B’s have a 5-on-5 Goals For/Against ratio of 2.38 in the playoffs, while Tampa is 1.26. I understand Tampa’s powerplay is lethal, but I still don’t get why so many analysts are picking Tampa… Rolly is playing out of his mind, but the Tampa D is average. Look to see the HuLK line out against St. Louis’ line in games 1 and 2, so that Looch can take advantage of playing opposite St. Louis.
Even sans-Bergy, if the B’s can knock the Lightning around like they did with Philly, I feel that the B’s will come out on top (knock on wood). Team defense wins championships.
I doubt we see other black aces unless there is more injury.
I think giving Campbell a whirl between Marchand and Recchi might work-but I suspect they move Peverly or Kelly to that position and put seguin on the 3rd line wing unless/until they opt to shorten his minutes then they might shift Campbell or Paille there.
Guess the good news is that they have some time to fool around with the adjustments before they actually have to play a game.
Also looks like the Predators gave us some help tonight and pushed their game 6 to Monday. Makes me think they will likely push the Bruins/Tampa start to next Wednesday or Thursday-to see what happens on Monday. While I was already hoping for a Predators win looks like I am going to be a Wings fan for the next couple of games.
I still have my doubts that the one week estimate will play out-I just can’t help but think if he is concussed that he is going to need more time to recover and while I would really love to see Bergeron return for the series I don’t want him to return if it means too much risk for him.
i am finding it really difficult to get past the bergy injury and enjoy the semis.
why does it have to be painful to be a b’s fan.
Losing Bergeron definitely put a damper on last night. Matt is probably right with what we’ll see for lines. Do you think we’ll see any other black aces?
@Paul, I was just thinking the same thing. Gotta say that the Kelly and Peverly pick ups make PC look better and better.
Well, Nashville just avoided elimination so that gives the B’s and Bergy at least another day.
Go Wings!
why not put campbell with recchi and marchand? campbell’s energy will blend well with marchand (as it did earlier this season on 4th line) and with recchi also. campbell will be defensively safe, and julien can spot in other centers such as kelly, peverly, krejci, or even seguin if he settles into the playoffs well enough. and as you even said, campbell brings in some offensive pop compared to the likes of begin and yelle.
the kelly line has stepped up and played like a second line for much of the playoffs production-wise, and maybe this sets back the recchi line to more of a third unit, but its one killer defensive unit to throw out there vs the big guns that tampa has.
also, like you pointed out, the 4th line has barely played. seguin’s inexperience will be limited, and the experience he gains will be huge for his development. and maybe seguin can get a little PP time and help that glaring weakness out. a few goals in the last 2 games only has me cautiously optimistic about that aspect of the B’s game. seguin’s speed, offensive flair, and youthful energy can only help out the struggling PP.
Very unfortunate that such a key cog on our team will be missing games. I’m hoping for nice long series out of the western conference–even though that seems unlikely right now.
Really hope Bergy can make a return (and still play a high-level game) around the third or fourth game of the series.
Go B’s!
Honestly I think the Bruins are done without Bergeron. They might eek out a series win against Tampa, but not a championship.
Although who knows, maybe the key players asked to do what they can to fill the Bergeron void will step it up and the team pulls off some massive wins, but I am just not that confident.
I find it hard to even enjoy the sweep of the Flyers when it means Bergeron is out and very possibly won’t return until next year (yes I know they have said it is mild, but this is Bergeron’s 3rd concussion and recovery may not have a time table that benefits the Bruins now-and it is far more important that Bergeron be healthy than that he comes back too soon only to have a set back).